I, Sarah Steinway
Finalist Debut Novel Category - 2018 National Jewish Book Awards
Sarah is an antihero for our age: a seventy-five-year-old woman, armed with her own
chutzpah and wit, a cowboy hat, a rabbinical ordination, and a shotgun that she’s still
figuring out how to use. The novel is set in the near future, in which a global flood is steadily
devouring the houses and Costcos of the world, but I, Sarah Steinway has a sensibility and
an immediacy that grounds us and grips us from the opening scene. Sarah wrestles with both
her physical and spiritual survival. As a self-identified secular Jew faced with an apocalypse
of biblical proportions, she turns to religion — not necessarily for answers, but for survival
tactics. This book, and its protagonist, are never afraid of confronting the Big Questions, nor
content to settle with easy answers. The storytelling is by turns very funny and very serious,
confident and uncompromisingly weird. Mary E. Carter has a voice with unquestionable
power, and we look forward to reading more from her. —Judges’ Remarks
—Review from Jewish Book Council—
By Inger SaphireBernstein
– April 9, 2019
Sarah Steinway, seventy five years old, is a survivor of the catastrophic Emperor Floods that
covered the Pacific coast cities and erased the boundaries of the San Francisco Bay, leaving
no dry shore until New Mexico. With a manual typewriter, in her treehouse perch above the
black waters of the former San Francisco Bay, she describes her experiences for future
readers (if there are any). She writes of death, beauty, and savagery (there is an
unforgettable scene of a vicious battle between shorebirds). She meets several interesting
survivors who arrive at her treehouse, including two rabbis. And she starts to think about
God and turns to the Torah.
As with most dystopian novels, the reader is anxious to know the cause of the killing
catastrophe. Apparently, at first, the water level increases of an inch or two every other week
were barely noticed. The people were told it was ‘fake news’ and that reports of rising waters
were false, going against visual evidence; most people complied. Periodic high tides and
flooding suddenly became the Emperor Floods that drowned all before it and never receded.
This is a very Jewish novel. Sarah provides midrashim (commentary) on the Torah. We are
treated to an interview with Noah’s wife, an explanation as to why Pharaoh’s daughter drew
Moses out of the Nile, and a return to Noah and God’s promise to never again flood the
world. Quotes from Pirkei Avot head each chapter. Aside from these formal efforts, Jewish
references crop up frequently. Sarah writes lovingly about her husband Daniel, her bashert.
She recognizes a congruence with Sarah in the Torah, who laughed when told she would give
birth at ninety, while Sarah Steinway births a treehouse at seventy-five. And Sarah Steinway
says she will not be edited out, like Noah’s wife and Sarah. Oddly, many of the people Sarah
meets before and during the flood are Jewish; drowned Marin County might be a shtetl given
its density of Jews.
One element in the novel is particularly perplexing. Sarah has several opportunities to go to
higher ground in New Mexico – to “choose life” rather than bear survival. She chooses to
remain in her treehouse, close to her greatest love, her Taliesin house, designed by a student
of Frank Lloyd Wright. Her love for the house is woven into her love for her late husband,
Daniel. In the Acknowledgements, Mary Carter describes the novel as a love letter to her
Taliesin home. Proximity to a drowned house seems like a poor trade-off for years of solitude
and deprivation above a catastrophic flood. Perhaps one has to love a house deeply to
understand.
Inger Saphire-Bernstein is a health policy professional with extensive experience across
multiple health care delivery settings and the insurance industry. She has published a
number of articles and papers in the health policy field.